Goalkeepers — Mike Payne (Akron), Chris West (Kentucky); Defenders — Andy Beall (Western Michigan), Pat Gerak (Kentucky), Desmond Johnston (Akron), Brian Mitchell (Akron), Kile Prewitt (Eastern Michigan); Midfielders — Jason Began (Bowling Green), Joe Burch (Bowling Green), Brian Dausman (Kentucky), Brandon Hardy (Miami), Steve Klein (Bowling Green), Justin Millard (Akron), Frank Ross (Akron); Forwards — Sean Mondelli (Kentucky), Dustin Swinehart (Miami), Todd Weissmueller (Kentucky).
Player of the Year — Dustin Swinehart (Miami)
Co-Newcomers of the Year — Justin Millard (Akron), Sean Endicott (Kentucky)
Coach of the Year — Ken Lolla (Akron)