1983 — Jamie Swanner (Clemson)
1984 — Jim Leahy (Brandeis)
1985 — Warren Lipka (South Carolina)
1986 — Jeff Duback (Yale)
1987 — Bob Willen (Virginia)
1988 — Charles Arndt (South Carolina)
1989 — Anton Nistl (UCLA)
1990 — Juergen Sommer (Indiana)
1991 — Kasey Keller (Portland)
1992 — Brad Friedel (UCLA)
1993 — Bo Oshoniyi (So. Connecticut)
1994 — David Kramer (Fresno State)