1985 — Gina Burrows (Hartwick)
1986 — Mary Harvey (California)
1987 — Amy Allman (Central Florida)
1988 — Janine Szpara (Colorado College)
1989 — Jen Starr (Vermont)
1990 — Karen Richter (Central Florida)
1991 — Heather Taggart (Wisconsin)
1992 — Saskia Webber (Rutgers)
1993 — Brianna Scurry (Massachusetts)
1994 — Jen Mead (George Mason)