East Division
Goalkeeper — Anthony Sardo (Central Connecticut); Defenders — Gareth Butcher (Central Connecticut), Brian Cruickshank (Buffalo), Kyle Fletcher (Central Connecticut); Midfielders — Dan Clolek (Buffalo), Steven Jarvis (Central Connecticut), Joe Mercik (Buffalo), Wayne Peachey (Central Connecticut); Forwards — Steve Robertson (Valparaiso), Leo Sfondouris (NE Illinois), Stephen Yanosy (Central Connecticut).
West Division
Goalkeeper — Mike Bristol (Western Illinois); Defender — Rob Ducey (UMKC); Midfielders — Bryan Blakemore (Western Illinois), Ryan Brown (Western Illinois), David Gee (SIU-Edwardsville), Brian Holcombe (Eastern Illinois), Keith Pavelka (Western Illinois); Forwards — Mike Anderson (UMKC), Brendan Flanagan (UMKC), Gary Hylton (Quincy), Mike Verning (Western Illinois).
Player of the Year — Steven Jarvis (Central Connecticut)
Newcomer of the Year — David Gee (SIU-Edwardsville)
Coach of the Year — John MacKenzie (Western Illinois)