Goalkeeper
- Tony Meola (2) MetroStars
Defenders
- Uche Okafor (1) Kansas City
- Ian Butterworth (1) Colorado
- Nicola Caricola (1) MetroStars
- Matt Kmosko (2) Colorado
Midfielders
- John Harkes (2) Washington
- Marco Etcheverry (5) Washington
- Roberto Donadoni (1) MetroStars
- Michael Emenalo (2) San Jose
Forwards
- Eric Wynalda (1) San Jose
- Shaun Bartlett (3) Colorado
Goal of the Week: Nicola Caricola (MetroStars vs. Columbus)
In parantheses are the number of times a player has been named to the Team of the Week.