First Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College | Hometown |
| GK | Keisha Coombs | So. | Monroe CC (N.Y.) | Hilton, N.Y. |
| D | Dawn Homont | So. | Ocean City (N.J.) | Toms River, N.J. |
| D | Tara Hurley | So. | Champlain (Vt.) | Milton, Vt. |
| D | Allison Satterthwait | So. | Brevard (N.C.) | Longwood, Fla. |
| MF | Staci Dowdy | So. | Lewis & Clark CC (Ill.) | Granite City, Ill. |
| MF | Anne Meier | So. | St. Louis CC-Meramec (Mo.) | Florissant, Mo. |
| MF | Megan Nelson | So. | Ohlone (Calif.) | Fremont, Calif. |
| MF | Danielle Wade | So. | St. Louis CC-Flo Valley (Mo.) | Florissant, Mo. |
| F | Cassidie Dunbar | Cantonsville CC (Md.) | Edgewater, Md. | |
| F | Amy Koudelka | So. | Monroe CC (N.Y.) | Williamson, N.Y. |
| F | Jessica Mackewicz | Fr. | American River (Calif.) | Rancho Cordova, Calif. |
| F | Liz Toye | So. | Grossmont (Calif.) | La Mesa, Calif. |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College | Hometown |
| GK | Cynthia Mendel | So. | Hill JC (Texas) | DeSoto, Texas |
| D | Stacey Frohlich | So. | St. Louis CC-Meramec (Mo.) | St. Louis, Mo. |
| D | Kelly Reabe | So. | Essex CC (N.J.) | Baltimore, Md. |
| D | Cathy Stratakis | Fr. | SUNY-Farmingdale (N.Y.) | Elmont, N.Y. |
| MF | Shannon Cromwell | So. | Genesee CC (N.Y.) | Royal Oak, Mich. |
| MF | Adrienne Duarte | So. | Fresno City College (Calif.) | Visalia, Calif. |
| MF | Kate Mathany | Fr. | American River (Calif.) | Fair Oaks, Calif. |
| MF | Holly Palombi | So. | Brevard (N.C.) | Rockford, Ill. |
| MF | Vicki Wagner | So. | Ocean County (N.J.) | Jackson, N.J. |
| F | Cristine Canle | So. | SUNY-Farmingdale (N.Y.) | Lynbrook, N.Y. |
| F | Maria Lara | So. | Brevard (N.C.) | Florissant, Mo. |
| F | Jackie Parkhill | So. | Mt. San Antonio CC (Calif.) | San Gabriel, Calif. |