First Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College |
| GK | Jon Busch | Junior | UNC Charlotte |
| D | Tahj Jakins | Senior | UCLA |
| D | Pete Santora | Senior | Furman |
| D | John Stratton | Senior | Air Force |
| MF | Mike Fisher | Senior | Virginia |
| MF | Steve Klein | Senior | Bowling Green |
| MF | Mike Mekelburg | Senior | South Florida |
| F | Tony Kuhn | Junior | Vanderbilt |
| F | Ignace Moleka | Senior | Florida International |
| F | Johnny Torres | Junior | Creighton |
| F | Andrew Williams | Junior | Rhode Island |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College |
| GK | Anthony Latronica | Junior | Rhode Island |
| D | Jason Annicchero | Senior | Santa Clara |
| D | Mathew Chulis | Sophomore | Virginia |
| D | Leo Cullen | Junior | Maryland |
| MF | Lazo Alavanja | Sophomore | Indiana |
| MF | Rob Elliott | Senior | Cornell |
| MF | Ben Hickey | Senior | St. John’s |
| MF | Will Kohler | Senior | Harvard |
| F | Siggi Eyjolfsson | Sophomore | UNC Greensboro |
| F | Bjorn Hansen | Senior | Northeastern |
| F | Rob Jachym | Senior | Hartford |
| F | Thomas Sheldon | Junior | Cal State Fullerton |
Third Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College |
| GK | Scott Coufal | Senior | Indiana |
| D | Alan Branigan | Junior | Rutgers |
| D | Danny Care | Senior | Clemson |
| D | Jason Marlovits | Senior | Hartford |
| D | Josh Provan | Senior | Wisconsin |
| MF | Antonio Capasso | Senior | Notre Dame |
| MF | Daniel Hernandez | Junior | SMU |
| MF | Brian Johnson | Senior | Fresno State |
| MF | Alen Kozic | Sophomore | Florida International |
| F | Jeff Cunningham | Junior | South Florida |
| F | Waughn Hughes | Senior | William & Mary |
| F | Pasi Kinturi | Junior | Campbell |
| F | Bob Rhine | Sophomore | Connecticut |
| F | Michael Shaw | Senior | Rutgers |
Ray Buss, longtime coach at Fleetwood Area High School (Pa.) and the late Walt Chyzowych will be inducted into the NSCAA Hall of Fame in Oneonta, N.Y.
Lamar Hunt was named an NSCAA Honorary all-America for his exemplary service to the sport.