| Goalkeeper | |
| Marcus Hahnemann (1) | Colorado |
| Defenders | |
| Marcelo Balboa (3) | Colorado |
| Jorge Salcedo (2) | Columbus |
| Mark Santel (2) | Dallas |
| Dan Calichman (2) | Los Angeles |
| Midfielders | |
| Chris Armas (1) | Los Angeles |
| Diego Sonora (1) | Dallas |
| Alain Sutter (2) | Dallas |
| Strikers | |
| Shaun Bartlett (1) | Colorado |
| Marcelo Carrera (1) | Columbus |
| Dante Washington (2) | Dallas |