| Goalkeeper | |
| Mike Ammann (1) | Kansas City |
| Defenders | |
| Sean Bowers (1) | Kansas City |
| Marcelo Balboa (4) | Colorado |
| Matt Kmosko (1) | Colorado |
| Jeff Agoos (3) | D.C. United |
| Midfielders | |
| John Maessner (2) | D.C. United |
| Preki (2) | Kansas City |
| Marco Etcheverry (4) | D.C. United |
| Adrian Paz (3) | Colorado |
| Forwards | |
| Alberto Naveda (1) | New England |
| David Patino (1) | Colorado |