Here are the 1998 NSCAA Girls’ High School State Players of the Year, as compiled by high school coaches from around the country:
| Name | Year | Pos. | School | State |
| Jaime Carstensen | Jr. | MF | Ursuline HS | California |
| Kelly Rheem | Sr. | F | Arapahoe HS | Colorado |
| Vanessa Pruzinsky | Sr. | MF | Trumbull HS | Connecticut |
| Kesha Christoph | Sr. | MF | Tatnall School | Delaware |
| Alexis MacKenzie | Sr. | F | St. Thomas Aquinas HS | Florida |
| Jessica Winton | Jr. | F | Westminster School | Georgia |
| Emily Brown | Sr. | F | New Trier HS | Illinois |
| Kara Bryan | Sr. | MF | Carmel HS | Indiana |
| Jayme O’Bryan | Sr. | D | Blue Valley North HS | Kansas |
| Regan Wiesemann | Sr. | GK | Bowling Green HS | Kentucky |
| Caitlin Butler | Sr. | F | Winchester HS | Massachusetts |
| Kelly Jordan | Sr. | MF | Arundel HS | Maryland |
| Bryn Carlson | Sr. | MF | Deering HS | Maine |
| Megan Almanzo | Sr. | F | Robbinsdale Armstrong HS | Minnesota |
| Shelly Gruszka | Jr. | F | St. Joseph’s Academy | Missouri |
| Wendy Stuker | Jr. | MF | Capital HS | Montana |
| Sarah Pickens | Sr. | F | Greensboro Day School | North Carolina |
| Marianne Hall | Sr. | D | Londonberry HS | New Hampshire |
| Stephanie Smith | Sr. | F | Ramapo HS | New Jersey |
| Tara Alarid | Sr. | F | St. Pius X | New Mexico |
| Beth Totman | Sr. | F | South Side HS | New York |
| Melissa Gregg | Sr. | F | Archbishop Alter HS | Ohio |
| Jennifer Henley | Sr. | F | Central Bucks West HS | Pennsylvania |
| Carly Williamson | Sr. | MF | Barrington HS | Rhode Island |
| Meghan Chismark | Sr. | D | Houston HS | Tennessee |
| Michelle Wickwire | Sr. | F | Kingwood HS | Texas |
| Ilene Dixon | Sr. | F | Mountain View HS | Utah |
| Katie Johnson | Jr. | MF | Kempsville HS | Virginia |
| Jesse Wilhite | Sr. | D | Champlain-Valley Union HS | Vermont |
| Jenny Strachota | Sr. | D | DSHA | Wisconsin |
| Jennifer Watkins | Sr. | MF | Lander Valley HS | Wyoming |