Here are the 1998 NSCAA Women’s NCAA Division III All-Americas, as selected by NSCAA coaches from around the United States:
First Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Lisa Grefe | Junior | St. Benedict |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Kim Cwik | Senior | Wisc.-Stevens Point |
| Sarah Hilgenberg | Junior | Wellesley |
| Sarah Newland | Senior | Trinity (Texas) |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Julie Gick | Junior | Cortland State |
| Cindy Laudien | Junior | William Patterson |
| Kate Ryan-Reiling | Junior | Macalester |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Traci Tapp | Junior | Coll. of New Jersey |
| Brooke Epperson | Senior | Macalester |
| Natalie Flindt | Junior | Willamette |
| Katy Sturtz | Freshman | Ohio Wesleyan |
Second Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Laura Brenneman | Senior | Williams |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Lauren Franford | Junior | Gettysburg |
| Lisa Krug | Senior | William Smith |
| Eliza Meade | Senior | Amherst |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Aria Garsys | Junior | Rochester |
| Erin Killian | Senior | Kalamazoo |
| Amy Zombeck | Senior | Keene State |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Cindy Dostalek | Sophomore | UC San Diego |
| Tara Dyk | Senior | Calvin |
| Kathryn Holland | Junior | Trinity (Texas) |
| Johanna Klein | Junior | Mary Washington |
Third Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Robin Heard | Senior | Willamette |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Chrystyn Chambers | Sophomore | Washington (Mo.) |
| Erin DeMarco | Sophomore | Ithaca |
| Amy Perbach | Senior | Emory |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Kristen Doughty | Senior | Bowdoin |
| Whitney Jackson | Sophomore | Gettysburg |
| Cinnamon Pace | Junior | Univ. of Chicago |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Kim-An Hernandez | Senior | Conn. College |
| Charlene Jankowski | Senior | Clark |
| Shannon Keelan | Junior | Richard Stockton |
| Holly Roepke | Senior | Cal Lutheran |