Preseason No. 1 Santa Clara leads the way with four players on the first team, including player of the year candidates Mandy Clemens and Aly Wagner. There are also four Women’s World Cup veterans — Lorrie Fair (USA/North Carolina), Lisa Casagrande (Australia/Portland), Sharolta Nonen (Canada/Nebraska) and Isabelle Morneau (Canada/Nebraska) — on the two teams. FIRST TEAM
| POSITION | PLAYER | TEAM | YEAR |
| Goalkeeper | LaKeysia Beene | Notre Dame | Senior |
| Defender | Lorrie Fair | North Carolina | Senior |
| Defender | Danielle Slaton | Santa Clara | Sophomore |
| Defender | Lindsay Stoecker | North Carolina | Senior |
| Midfielder | Anne Makinen | Notre Dame | Junior |
| Midfielder | Rebekah McDowell | North Carolina | Senior |
| Midfielder | Nikki Serlenga | Santa Clara | Senior |
| Midfielder | Aly Wagner | Santa Clara | Freshman |
| Forward | Mandy Clemens | Santa Clara | Senior |
| Forward | Mary-Frances Monroe | Connecticut | Sophomore |
| Forward | Kelly Smith | Seton Hall | Senior |
SECOND TEAM | POSITION | PLAYER | TEAM | YEAR |
| Goalkeeper | Kristin Luckenbill | Dartmouth | Junior |
| Defender | Jen Grubb | Notre Dame | Senior |
| Defender | Heather Mitts | Florida | Senior |
| Defender | Sharolta Nonen | Nebraska | Senior |
| Midfielder | Ronnie Fair | Stanford | Senior |
| Midfielder | Asta Helgadottir | Vanderbilt | Junior |
| Midfielder | Isabelle Morneau | Nebraska | Senior |
| Midfielder | Jenny Streiffer | Notre Dame | Senior |
| Forward | Lisa Casagrande | Portland | Sophomore |
| Forward | Beth Keller | Clemson | Senior |
| Forward | Missy Wycinsky | William & Mary | Senior |
