1984 — Amr Aly (Columbia)
1985 — Mike Brady (American)
1986 — John Kerr (Duke)
1987 — Bruce Murray (Clemson)
1988 — Dan Donigan (Connecticut)
1989 — Rob Paterson (Evansville)
1990 — Billy Thompson (UCLA)
1991 — Henry Gutierrez (N.C. State)
1992 — Rob Ukrop (Davidson)
1993 — Brian McBride (St. Louis)
1994 — Brian Maisonneuve (Indiana)