Here are the 1998 NSCAA men’s NAIA All-Americas, as compiled by NSCAA coaches from around the United States:
First Team
| GOALKEEPERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Igor Ranitovic | Junior | Birmingham-Southern |
| Adam Throop | Junior | Westmont |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Robert Burgess | Senior | Berry |
| Vincent Kwarula | Freshman | Lindsey Wilson |
| Matt Miller | Senior | Mobile |
| Tony Pyle | Senior | Seattle |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Ryan Austin | Junior | Life |
| Milton Griffiths | Senior | William Carey |
| Jason Herrera | Senior | Illinois-Springfield |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Orlando Bueso | Senior | Lindsey Wilson |
| Stuart Connolly | Sophomore | Life |
| Bonaventure Maruti | Sophomore | Mobile |
| Daniel Nischwitz | Senior | Birmingham-Southern |
| Tom Odhiambo | Freshman | Lindsey Wilson |
Second Team
| GOALKEEPERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Richard Goddard | Sophomore | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Steve London | Junior | Simon Fraser |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Omar Brown | Senior | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Virgil Cannon | Sophomore | John Brown |
| Thorsten Damm | Junior | Birmingham-Southern |
| Chris Hook | Senior | Westmont |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Benjamin Dieukena | Junior | Lindsey Wilson |
| Brad Jenks | Junior | Columbia (Mo.) |
| Alan Koch | Junior | Simon Fraser |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Edgardo Contrearas | Sophomore | Fresno Pacific |
| Joey Melanson | Senior | Husson |
| Bryce Morrow | Senior | East Texas Baptist |
| Kurt Swanson | Senior | Seattle |
| Stan Thesenvitz | Senior | Seattle |
Third Team
| GOALKEEPERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Jeremy Dahl | Senior | St. Edwards |
| Jeremiah Doyle | Freshman | Seattle |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Jake Ashley | Senior | Lindenwood |
| Richard Bodnark | Senior | Simon Fraser |
| T.J. Fraase | Senior | Illinois-Springfield |
| Pablo Nassar | Sophomore | Life |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Craig Aitken | Senior | Berry |
| Matt Evans | Freshman | Azusa Pacific |
| Anthony Lowther | Freshman | Life |
| Nermin Ramic | Junior | National American |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Kerry Escayg | Senior | Goshen |
| Morteza Hirad | Senior | Pt. Loma Nazarene |
| Rayburn Moore | Senior | Baker |
| Jason Roufs | Senior | Azusa Pacific |