Here are the 1998 NSCAA men’s NCAA Division II All-Americas, as compiled by NSCAA coaches from around the United States:
First Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Jason Wright | Freshman | Quincy |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Gareth Dunn | Sophomore | Lynn |
| Mark Fitzgerald | Sophomore | Mercyhurst |
| Gilbert Jean-Baptiste | Senior | So. Connecticut |
| Darren Warham | Senior | Lynn |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Assaf Dagai | Junior | So. Connecticut |
| Alvaro Fiqueroia | Senior | Francis Marion |
| Rich Hansen | Senior | Fort Lewis |
| Milos Tomic | Senior | Grand Canyon |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| David Hayes | Senior | Wingate |
| Johan Kron | Junior | Southampton |
| Khari Sharieff | Sophomore | USC Spartanburg |
Second Team
| GOALKEEPERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Guillermo Gatti | Senior | So. Connecticut |
| Brandon Hearron | Senior | Cal State Bakersfield |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Luc Cisna | Junior | Fort Lewis |
| Jonathon Douglas | Senior | Quincy |
| John Koven | Junior | Humboldt State |
| Mats Nyqvist | Senior | New Hampshire Coll. |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Tyler Cornell | Junior | Cal State Chico |
| Chris Fernandez | Junior | Cal State Dominguez Hills |
| Joe Murray | Senior | Franklin Pierce |
| Jeremy Yorgason | BYU-Hawaii | |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Thomas Andreason | Senior | Rockhurst |
| Dana Garner | Junior | Seattle Pacific |
| Andy Thompson | Junior | Mars Hill |
| Richard Walker | Sophomore | New Hampshire Coll. |