Here are the 1998 NSCAA men’s NCAA Division III All-Americas, as compiled by NSCAA coaches from around the United States:
First Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Greg Sutton | Senior | St. Lawrence |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Stephen Danbusky | Senior | Williams |
| David Decew | Senior | Bowdoin |
| Lance Key | Junior | Trinity (Texas) |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Ben Hardy | Senior | Middlebury |
| Armin Heuberger | Senior | Macalester |
| Scott Mury | Junior | Trinity (Texas) |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Matt Diggs | Senior | Amherst |
| Robert Mouw | Junior | Wheaton (Ill.) |
| Richard Ronemus | Senior | Greensboro |
| Jason Vishio | Junior | Gettysburg |
Second Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Shawn Higgins | Senior | Plymouth State |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Luis Alcarez | Senior | Cal Lutheran |
| John Del Monaco | Junior | Johns Hopkins |
| Mike Paolini | Senior | SUNY-Plattsburg |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Martin Forman | Senior | Ohio Wesleyan |
| Jim Manganello | Senior | Wheaton (Mass.) |
| Kevin Martin | Junior | Plymouth |
| Nick Trebat | Senior | Williams |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Eric Brown | Junior | Wheaton (Ill.) |
| John Giannacopoulos | Junior | Middlebury |
| Kevin Jensen | Junior | St. Olaf |
| Ahmed Mohyeldin | Senior | Emory |
Third Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Eric Lukach | Sophomore | Cabrini |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Alex Kugel | Senior | St. Mary’s (Minn.) |
| Ali Montacer | Sophomore | St. Lawrence |
| Ryan Nelsen | Sophomore | Greensboro |
| Jason Passalacqua | Senior | Alma |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Mike Giuffrida | Senior | Salisbury State |
| Mike Hayes | Senior | Rowan |
| Jamie Pettengill | Junior | Earlham |
| Marlow Pollard | Senior | Montclair |
| Matt Albrecht | Senior | SUNY-Fredonia |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Brian Hagen | Senior | Wisc.-Platteville |
| Stuart Hulke | Sophomore | Roger Williams |
| Momodou Jagne | Sophomore | Wabash |
| Marvin Lopez | Senior | Drew |