Here are the 1998 NSCAA women’s NAIA All-Americas, as compiled by NSCAA coaches from around the United States:
First Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Kristen St. Clair | Sophomore | Westmont |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Jennifer Babel | Junior | Azusa Pacific |
| Roxanne Chow | Sophomore | Simon Fraser |
| Tracey Mulligan | Freshman | Mobile |
| Danielle Small | Sophomore | Mobile |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Andrea Alfiler | Sophomore | Azusa Pacific |
| Katie Gardinier | Junior | Westmont |
| Carmie Landeen | Senior | Mobile |
| Laila Modi | Junior | Berry |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Jackie Law | Sophomore | Mobile |
| Sara Maglio | Junior | Simon Fraser |
| Melissa Myers | Sophomore | Azusa Pacific |
| Kendra Payne | Sophomore | Azusa Pacific |
Second Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Kris Bashong | Senior | Lindenwood |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Leona Bass | Senior | Park |
| Heather Hiland | Sophomore | Berry |
| Nicole Jones | Junior | St. Thomas |
| Andrea Potteiger | Junior | Houghton |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Hedda Haugland | Freshman | Mobile |
| Randee Hemus | Sophomore | Simon Fraser |
| Lisa Poirier | Senior | Lindsey Wilson |
| Danielle Wade | Senior | Lindenwood |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Theresa Brough | Junior | St. Francis (Ind.) |
| Lindsay Grant | Senior | Mobile |
| Turtle Massman | Senior | Lindenwood |
| Tamara Williams | Sophomore | Lindsey Wilson |
Third Team
| GOALKEEPER | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Rachel Major | Senior | St. Mary’s (Texas) |
| DEFENDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Katie Kelley | Senior | So. California Coll. |
| Christy Olson | Junior | Concordia |
| Michelle Romero | Junior | Westmont |
| Nellie Sandoval | Junior | Friends |
| MIDFIELDERS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Janay Duran | Junior | Azusa Pacific |
| Tina Froberg | Freshman | Mobile |
| Stephanie Herivel | Junior | Westmont |
| Sunshine Leonard | Sophomore | Houghton |
| FORWARDS | ||
| Name | Year | College |
| Amber Buchanan | Junior | Lindenwood |
| Angela Morgan | Senior | Westmont |
| Jami Shaupe | Junior | Bellevue |
| Michelle Smith | Junior | St. Thomas |