Division I
First Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College | Hometown |
| GK | Cesar Delgado | So. | Yavapai (Ariz.) | Phoenix, Ariz. |
| D | Daniel Balaguero | So. | Champlain (Vt.) | Nottingham, England |
| D | Matt Patana | So. | St. Louis CC (Forest Park, Mo.) | St. Louis, Mo. |
| MF | Oliver Balson | So. | Dekalb (Ga.) | Lilburn, Ga. |
| MF | Wojtek Kapuscik | So. | DuPage (Ill.) | Hanover Park, Ill. |
| MF | Jesus Ledesma | So. | Tyler (Texas) | Tyler, Texas |
| F | Manoel Coehlo | Fr. | Mesa CC (Ariz.) | Mesa, Ariz. |
| F | Daid Hayes | So. | Charles County CC (Md.) | Waldorf, Md. |
| F | James Martino | Fr. | Essex CC (N.J.) | Brooklyn, N.Y. |
| F | Nolan Napier | Fr. | Massasoit (Mass.) | Brockton, Mass. |
| F | Graham Parker | So. | Mercer County CC (N.J>) | Bray, Ireland |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College | Hometown |
| GK | Ebou Nije | So. | Essex CC (N.J.) | Newark, N.J. |
| D | Aidan Byrne | So. | Mount Ida (Md.) | Dublin, Ireland |
| D | Roger Chambers | Fr. | Monroe CC (N.Y.) | St. Albans, N.Y. |
| D | Samuel Luo | So. | Lincoln Land CC (Ill.) | Springfield, Ill. |
| MF | Frank Kucinic | So. | Lakeland CC (Ohio) | Willoughby, Ohio |
| MF | Josue Sabillon | So. | Meridian CC (Miss.) | New Orleans, La. |
| MF | Steve Ybarra | So. | Yavapai (Ariz.) | Peoria, Ariz. |
| F | James Martin | So. | Mitchell (Conn.) | New London, Conn. |
| F | Mark Ozgar | So. | Catonsville (Md.) | Eldersburg, Md. |
| F | Bryan Spray | So. | St. Louis CC (Forest Park, Mo.) | St. Louis, Mo. |
| F | Brandon Winn | So. | Allen County CC (Kan.) | Belton, Mo. |
Division III
First Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College | Hometown |
| GK | James Karl | So. | Anne Arundel CC (Md.) | Annapolis, Md. |
| D | Jordi Esteban | So. | American River (Calif.) | Davis, Calif. |
| D | Michael Iannelli | So. | Herkimer County CC (N.Y.) | Warnerville, N.Y. |
| D | Garfield Walker | So. | Manchester Tech CC (Conn.) | Windsor, Conn. |
| MF | Derek Josted | Fr. | Modesto JC (Calif.) | Modesto, Calif. |
| MF | Jamie Lumsden | So. | Burlington County (N.J.) | Willingburo, N.J. |
| MF | Jason Robinson | Fr. | Herkimer County CC (N.Y.) | Endicott, N.Y. |
| F | Hector Vargas | So. | Prince George’s CC (Md.) | Adelphi, Md. |
| F | Charles Sells | Fr. | Fresno City College (Calif.) | Clovis, Calif. |
| F | Flemming Sorensen | So. | Santa Barbara City College (Calif.) | Santa Barbara, |
| Calif. | ||||
| F | Matthew Tanzini | So. | Herkimer County CC (N.Y.) | Lewiston, N.Y. |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | College | Hometown |
| GK | Robert Culazzo | So. | Canada (Calif.) | Mountain View, Calif. |
| D | Cesar Baltazar | So. | Hartnell CC (Calif.) | Watsonville, Calif. |
| D | Petr Rais | So. | Montgomery (Md.) | Bethesda, Md. |
| D | Chris Yantos | Fr. | Canada (Calif.) | San Carlos, Calif. |
| MF | Beny Bujdei | So. | Triton (Ill.) | River Forest, Ill. |
| MF | Brandon Pace | So. | Fresno City College (Calif.) | Visalia, Calif. |
| MF | Charles Pratt | Fr. | Jefferson CC (N.Y.) | New Hartford, N.Y. |
| MF | Steven Spang | So. | Santa Rosa JC (Calif.) | Jacksonville, Ore. |
| F | Flavius Ardelean | Fr. | Triton (Ill.) | Chicago, Ill. |
| F | Javier Calvo | So. | Burlington County (N.J.) | Mt. Holly, N.J. |
| F | Rory Carr | Fr. | Raritan Valley CC (N.J.) | Neshanic, N.J. |