1967 — Dov Markus (Long Island)
1968 — Manny Hernandez (San Jose State)
1969 — Al Trost (St. Louis)
1970 — Al Trost (St. Louis)
1971 — Mike Seerey (St. Louis)
1972 — Mike Seerey (St. Louis)
1973 — Dan Counce (St. Louis)
1974 — Farrukh Quraishi (Oneonta State)
1975 — Steve Ralbovsky (Brown)
1976 — Glenn Myernick (Hartwick)
1977 — Billy Gazonas (Hartwick)
1978 — Angelo DiBernando (Indiana)
1979 — Jim Stamitas (Penn State)
1980 — Joe Morrone Jr. (Connecticut)
1981 — Armando Betancourt (Indiana)
1982 — Joe Ulrich (Duke)
1983 — Mike Jeffries (Duke)
1984 — Amr Aly (Columbia)
1985 — Tom Kain (Duke)
1986 — John Kerr (Duke)
1987 — Bruce Murray (Clemson)
1988 — Ken Snow (Indiana)
1989 — Tony Meola (Virginia)
1990 — Ken Snow (Indiana)
1991 — Alexi Lalas (Rutgers)
1992 — Brad Friedel (UCLA)
1993 — Claudio Reyna (Virginia)
1994 — Brian Maisonneuve (Indiana)
1995 — Mike Fisher (Virginia)
1996 — Mike Fisher (Virginia)