1959
St. Louis 5, Bridgeport 2
1960
St. Louis 3, Maryland 2
1961
West Chester 2, St. Louis 0
1962
St. Louis 4, Maryland 3
1963
St. Louis 3, Navy 0
1964
Navy 1, Michigan State 0
1965
St. Louis 1, Michigan State 0
1966
San Francisco 5, Long Island 2
1967
Michigan State 0, St. Louis 0
(Game called due to inclement weather; Michigan State and St. Louis declared co-champions)
1968
Michigan State 2, Maryland 2 (OT)
(Michigan State and Maryland declared co-champions)
1969
St. Louis 4, San Francisco 0
1970
St. Louis 1, UCLA 0
1971
Howard 3, St. Louis 2
(NCAA vacated title)
1972
St. Louis 4, UCLA 2
1973
St. Louis 2, UCLA 1
1974
Howard 2, St. Louis 1 (OT)
1975
San Francisco 4, SIU-Edwardsville 0
1976
San Francisco 1, Indiana 0
1977
Hartwick 2, San Francisco 1
1978
San Francisco 2, Indiana 0
(NCAA vacated title)
1979
SIU-Edwardsville 3, Clemson 2
1980
San Francisco 4, Indiana 3 (OT)
1981
Connecticut 2, Alabama A&M 1 (OT)
1982
Indiana 2, Duke 1 (OT)
1983
Indiana 1, Columbia 0 (OT)
1984
Clemson 2, Indiana 1
1985
UCLA 1, American 0 (OT)
1986
Duke 1, Akron 0
1987
Clemson 2, San Diego St. 0
1988
Indiana 1, Howard 0
1989
Santa Clara 1, Virginia 1 (OT)
(Santa Clara and Virginia declared co-champions)
1990
UCLA 0, Rutgers 0 (OT)
(UCLA wins on penalty kicks)
1991
Virginia 0, Santa Clara 0 (OT)
(Virginia wins on penalty kicks)
1992
Virginia 2, San Diego 0
1993
Virginia 2, South Carolina 0
1994
Virginia 1, Indiana 0
1995
Wisconsin 2 Duke 0
1996
St. John’s 4 Florida International 1