1984 — Paul DiBernardo (Indiana)
1985 — Michael Brady (American)
1986 — Paul Caligiuri (UCLA), John Kerr (Duke)
1987-91 — no winner
1992 — Claudio Reyna (Virginia)
1993 — Claudio Reyna (Virginia)
1994 — A.J. Wood (Virginia)
1995 — Mike Fisher (Virginia)
1996 — Johnny Torres (Creighton)