First Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | School |
| GK | Greg Meyer | Senior | Colorado-Colorado Springs |
| D | Matt Harmer | Senior | Pfeiffer |
| D | Mark Moore | Senior | New Hampshire Coll. |
| D | Mike Petke | Senior | Southern Connecticut |
| D | Darren Warham | Junior | Lynn |
| MF | Jon Akin | Junior | St. Leo |
| MF | Ross Comeaux | Senior | Alabama-Huntsville |
| MF | Matt Little | Junior | Southern Illinois |
| MF | Anders Paulsson | Senior | Tampa |
| MF | Calum Robertson | Junior | Fort Lewis |
| F | Anton Brown | Senior | Lander |
| F | Sean Crawford | Senior | East Stroudsburg |
| F | Itai Mor | Senior | Southern Connecticut |
| F | Joe Munoz | Senior | Cal State Bakersfield |
| F | Henrick Nebrelius | Junior | Tampa |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | School |
| GK | Ante Cop | Senior | New Hampshire Coll. |
| GK | Jeremy Ransom | Senior | Presbyterian |
| D | Gareth Dunn | Freshman | Lynn |
| D | John Koven | Sophomore | Humboldt State |
| D | Josef Schroeder | Senior | Francis Marion |
| D | Paul Zgalich | Senior | USC-Spartanburg |
| MF | Quincy Aberdeen | Sophomore | Augusta State |
| MF | Steve McAuliffe | Senior | Merrimack |
| MF | Kevin Yearick | Senior | Queens |
| MF | Jason Zitzke | Junior | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| F | David Hayes | Junior | Wingate |
| F | Markus Pfeiler | Sophomore | Franklin Pierce |
| F | Khari Sharieff | Freshman | USC-Spartanburg |
| F | Steve Slack | Senior | Lock Haven |
| F | Christopher Ziemer | Junior | Sonoma State |