First Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | School |
| GK | Brandy Jones | Junior | Barry |
| D | Amy Apodaca | Sophomore | Sonoma State |
| D | Jennifer Newkirk | Senior | West Virginia Wesleyan |
| D | Courtney Swanson | Freshman | Presbyterian |
| MF | Paullinia Auveri | Senior | Franklin Pierce |
| MF | Julie Bugg | Junior | Bloomsburg |
| MF | Marie Kolbert | Sophomore | Lynn |
| MF | Laura Martin | Senior | Adelphi |
| F | Paulina Miettinen | Junior | Franklin Pierce |
| F | Jannie Nicolaisen | Freshman | Lynn |
| F | Tiffany Thompson | Freshman | Mesa State |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | Year | School |
| GK | Tracy Wirth | Junior | Bloomsburg |
| D | Cheryl Bates | Freshman | Mesa State |
| D | Nicole Esposito | Senior | Mercyhurst |
| D | Diane Wagner | Senior | Sonoma State |
| MF | Heather Jones | Junior | Presbyterian |
| MF | Jacelyn Parisi | Junior | Truman State |
| MF | Lotta Thunberg | Junior | New Hampshire Coll. |
| F | Juli Hanrath | Junior | West Virginia Wesleyan |
| F | Rosa Lappi-Seppala | Sophomore | Barry |
| F | Terri Meierhopper | Senior | East Stroudsburg |
| F | Heather Rolland | Senior | Cal State Dominguez Hills |