First Team
Goalkeeper — Michael Oehlmann (Rowan); Defenders — Tom Auchenbach (Muhlenberg), Kenneth Hoey (Methodist), Terry Kaufman (Williams); Midfielders — Wayne Albertyn (Kenyon), Gary DePalma (Virginia Wesleyan), Doug Hess (Elizabethtown); Forwards — Tim Averell (Muhlenberg), Obi Moneme (Ohio Wesleyan), Brad Murray (Williams), Chris Tassy (Messiah).
Second Team
Goalkeeper — Scott Morgenroth (Virginia Wesleyan); Defenders —
Dave Cherosky (Hiram), Jeff Kramer (Mary Washington), Cullen Meade (Middlebury); Midfielders — Kari Reynisson (Methodist), Peter Rogaris (Williams), Jeremy Sorzano (Messiah); Forwards — Jason Caims (Trenton), Tom Cordaro (Fredonia), Mario Watts (Amherst), Evan Whitson (Virginia Wesleyan).
Third Team
Goalkeeper — Aaron Angell (Hope); Defenders — David Blomquist (Wheaton, Ill.), William Gordon (Rhodes), Brian Theirrin (Greensboro); Midfielders — John Conlan (Hope), Gary Hurtarte (Chapman), Ian Myles (Montclair), Jody Tootle (Maryville); Forwards — Darnell Chambers (Heidelburg), Erick Hurtarte (Chapman), Matt Tirschman (Salisbury), Jason Walker (Rochester), Josh Will (Centre).