Defending champion North Carolina tops the list with four players, while NCAA semifinalist Santa Clara has three players. There are two Olympians — Santa Clara’s Danielle Slaton (USA) and Oakland’s Anita Rapp (Norway) — and three Women’s World Cup ’99 players — Rapp, Nebraska’s Karina LeBlanc (Canada) and USC’s Isabelle Harvey (Canada).
FIRST TEAM
| PLAYER | TEAM | YEAR |
| Goalkeeper | ||
| Karina LeBlanc | Nebraska | Sr. |
| Defenders | ||
| Keisha Bell | Florida | Jr. |
| Danielle Borgman | North Carolina | Jr. |
| Danielle Slaton | Santa Clara | Jr. |
| Midfielders | ||
| Isabelle Harvey | USC | Sr. |
| Anne Makinen | Notre Dame | Sr. |
| Aly Wagner | Santa Clara | Soph. |
| Forwards | ||
| Susan Bush | North Carolina | So. |
| Mary-Frances Monroe | Connecticut | Jr. |
| Abby Wambach | Florida | Jr. |
| Christie Welsh | Penn State | Soph. |
SECOND TEAM
| PLAYER | TEAM | YEAR |
| Goalkeeper | ||
| Jenni Branam | North Carolina | Soph. |
| Defenders | ||
| Anna Kraus | Santa Clara | Jr. |
| Sarah Powell | Boston College | Sr. |
| Nandi Pryce | UCLA | Fr. |
| Midfielders | ||
| Meghan Anderson | Nebraska | Jr. |
| Aleisha Cramer | BYU | Fr. |
| Jena Kluegel | North Carolina | Jr. |
| Anita Rapp | Oakland | Sr. |
| Stacey Tullock | Arizona State | Jr. |
| Forwards | ||
| Missy Gregg | Dayton | Soph. |
| Nikki Thole | Missouri | Sr. |