1986 — John Kerr (Duke)
1987 — John Harkes (Virginia)
1988 — Ken Snow (Indiana)
1989 — Tony Meola (Virginia)
1990 — Ken Snow (Indiana)
1991 — Alexi Lalas (Rutgers)
1992 — Claudio Reyna (Virginia)
1993 — Claudio Reyna (Virginia)
1994 — Todd Yeagley (Indiana)