| Goalkeeper | |
| Dave Salzwedel (2) | San Jose |
| Defenders | |
| Jorge Salcedo (1) | Columbus |
| Richard Gough (1) | Kansas City |
| Cle Kooiman (2) | Tampa Bay |
| Steve Trittschuh (3) | Colorado |
| Midfielders | |
| Steve Ralston (2) | Tampa Bay |
| Carlos Valderrama (2) | Tampa Bay |
| Brian Maisonneuve (2) | Columbus |
| Doctor Khumalo (1) | Columbus |
| Forwards | |
| Raul Diaz Arce (2) | D.C. United |
| Brian McBride (2) | Columbus |