Goalkeeper
| Mark Dodd (2) | Dallas |
Defenders
| Steve Trittschuh (2) | Colorado |
| Marcelo Balboa (2) | Colorado |
| Eddie Pope (3) | D.C. United |
| Jeff Agoos (1) | D.C.United |
Midfielders
| Brian Maisonneuve (1) | Columbus |
| Alain Sutter (1) | Dallas |
| Adrian Paz (2) | Colorado |
Forwards
| Jaime Moreno (4) | D.C. United |
| Chiquinho Conde (2) | New England |
| Brian McBride (1) | Columbus |