1984 — Fairleigh Dickinson
1985 — Long Island
1986 — Long Island
1987 — Loyola (Md.)
1988 — Fairleigh Dickinson
1989 — Fairleigh Dickinson
1990 — Monmouth
1991 — St. Francis (N.Y.)
1992 — Rider
1993 — Robert Morris
1994 — Robert Morris
1995 — St. Francis (N.Y.)