| State | Name | Year | Pos. | School |
| Alaska | Paul Gonzales | Sr. | D | Dimond |
| Arizona | Sasha Hunter | Sr. | F | Corona del Sol |
| California | Sasha Victorine | Sr. | MF | Rio Americano |
| Colorado | Wesley Hart | Sr. | MF | Columbine |
| Connecticut | Andrew McConville | Sr. | MF | Daniel Hand |
| Delaware | Colin Carew | Sr. | D | Newark |
| Florida | Dustin Reineke | Sr. | F | William R. Boone |
| Georgia | Josh Wolff | Sr. | F | Parkview |
| Hawaii | Dereck Heresa | Jr. | F | Iolani School |
| Idaho | Phillip Harris | Sr. | MF | Meridian |
| Illinois | Nino DaSilva | Jr. | F | Saint Viator |
| Indiana | Kei Tennyson | Jr. | F | North Central |
| Iowa | Michael Enright | Sr. | MF | Bettendorf |
| Kansas | Cory Engkjer | Sr. | MF | Wichita Northwest |
| Kentucky | David Wright | Sr. | MF | Ballard |
| Louisiana | Ty Montet | Sr. | D | St. Louis Catholic |
| Maine | Josh McGeachey | So. | MF | Cape Elizabeth |
| Maryland | Brian West | Fr. | F | Centennial |
| Massachusetts | Ben Figueiredo | Sr. | MF | New Bedford |
| Michigan | Anders Kelto | Sr. | MF | Traverse City |
| Minnesota | Kareem Aal | Sr. | MF | Minneapolis South |
| Missouri | Jeremy Iwaszkowiec | Sr. | F | Howell Norris |
| North Carolina | Jorge Redmond | Sr. | F | T.C. Robinson |
| New Hampshire | Kris Keenan | Sr. | F | Gilford Middle |
| New Jersey | Doug Brooks | Sr. | GK | Roxbury |
| New York | Dimitry Kovalenko | Sr. | MF | Greece Arcadia |
| Ohio | Doug Swaney | Sr. | GK | Centerville |
| Oregon | Jesse Butler | Jr. | F | La Salle |
| Pennsylvania | Ryan O’Neill | Sr. | MF | Strath Haven |
| Rhode Island | Brian Rosa | Sr. | MF | Portsmouth |
| Tennessee | Henry Ring | Sr. | GK | Brentwood |
| Texas | Tomas Melchor | Sr. | MF | Spring |
| Utah | Wade Van Horn | Sr. | MF | Jordan |
| Virginia | Josh Dunn | Sr. | MF | Lake Braddock |
| Washington | Michael Casale | Jr. | D | Eastlake |
| Wisconsin | Dennis Fadeski | Sr. | F | Brookfield East |
| Wyoming | Jared White | Sr. | F | East |
National Boys Player of the Year
Sasha Victorine (Rio Americano — California)