| State | Name | Year | Pos. | School |
| California | Beth Thompson | Sr. | MF | Montgomery |
| Colorado | Rachel Weber | So. | MF | Niwot |
| Connecticut | Carey Dorn | Sr. | MF | William Hall |
| Delaware | Kesha Christoph | Fr. | MF | The Tatnall School |
| Florida | Jennifer O’Sullivan | Sr. | D | Springstead |
| Georgia | Rakel Karvelsson | Sr. | MF | McIntosh |
| Illinois | Jenny Grubb | Jr. | MF | James B. Conant |
| Indiana | Lori Lindsey | So. | F | Pike |
| Kentucky | Nikki Armento | Jr. | MF | South Oldham |
| Maine | Christine Huber | Sr. | F | Cony |
| Maryland | Laurie Schwoy | Sr. | F | McDonogh |
| Massachusetts | Gina Pantuosco | Sr. | F | Cathedral |
| Minnesota | Sarah Blaska | Sr. | F | Anoka |
| Missouri | Tracy Grose | Sr. | F | Howell North |
| New Hampshire | Courtney Banghart | Sr. | F | Souhegan |
| New Jersey | Tricia Williams | Jr. | F | Shawnee |
| New Mexico | Jessica Larson | Sr. | MF | La Cueva |
| New York | Lindsey Prevo | Sr. | MF | South Side |
| North Carolina | Lindsay Stoecker | Jr. | MF | Broughton |
| Ohio | Jessica Moorman | Sr. | MF | Hudson |
| Pennsylvania | Tiffany Keyes | Sr. | MF | Central Dauphin E. |
| Rhode Island | Emily Feeney | Sr. | F | North Kingstown |
| South Carolina | Liz Speights | Jr. | F | Wando |
| Tennessee | Deanna Stayton | Sr. | F | Dobyns-Bennett |
| Texas | Gina Castellano | Jr. | MF | James Martin |
| Utah | Mackenzie Hyer | Jr. | GK | Alta |
| Virginia | Angela Hucles | Jr. | F | Norfolk Academy |
| Vermont | Jennifer Carlson | Jr. | F | Champlain Valley Union |
| Washington | Meotis Erikson | Jr. | F | Kamiakin |
| Wisconsin | Jenny Heft | Jr. | F | St. Pius X |
National Girls Player of the Year
Laurie Schwoy (McDonogh — Maryland)