The following are the results of the SA Online May poll in which 941 fans voted for the U.S. lineup for the World Cup qualifying match against El Salvador on June 28. Based on the voting, fans would prefer to have Kasey Keller in goal, with (in order of votes received) Eric Wynalda, John Harkes, Claudio Reyna, Eddie Pope, Thomas Dooley, Marcelo Balboa, Ernie Stewart, Jeff Agoos, Alexi Lalas, and Michael Mason in the field. Here is the complete vote tally:
Goalkeeper
| Player | Votes |
| *Kasey Keller | 722 |
| Brad Friedel | 97 |
| Tony Meola | 83 |
| Mark Dodd | 29 |
| Juergen Sommer | 10 |
Field Players
| Player | Votes |
| *Eric Wynalda | 823 |
| *John Harkes | 792 |
| *Claudio Reyna | 774 |
| *Eddie Pope | 767 |
| *Thomas Dooley | 704 |
| *Marcelo Balboa | 688 |
| *Ernie Stewart | 656 |
| *Jeff Agoos | 604 |
| *Alexi Lalas | 466 |
| *Michael Mason | 385 |
| David Wagner | 349 |
| Roy Lassiter | 320 |
| Cobi Jones | 303 |
| Brian McBride | 285 |
| Mike Sorber | 245 |
| Preki Radosavljevic | 191 |
| Joe-Max Moore | 168 |
| Jovan Kirovski | 121 |
| John Doyle | 112 |
| Frankie Hejduk | 89 |
| Mike Burns | 79 |
| Jason Kreis | 65 |
| Cle Kooiman | 52 |
| Dan Calichman | 49 |
| Mike Duhaney | 41 |
| Robin Fraser | 41 |
| Mike Lapper | 38 |
| Tony Sanneh | 37 |
| Richie Williams | 34 |
| Steve Pittman | 33 |
| Peter Vermes | 32 |
| Steve Ralston | 30 |
| Greg Vanney | 10 |