1985 — Lisa Gmitter (George Mason)
1986 — April Heinrichs (North Carolina)
1987 — Michelle Akers (Central Florida)
1988 — Shannon Higgins (North Carolina)
1989 — Shannon Higgins (North Carolina)
1990 — Kristine Lilly (North Carolina)
1991 — Julie Foudy (Stanford)
1992 — Mia Hamm (North Carolina)
1993 — Mia Hamm (North Carolina)
1994 — Tisha Venturini (North Carolina)